It's not often that you come away from a Disney movie and can launch into moral and ethical discussions with your children. Maleficent [2014 Disney] proved to be a deliciously different offering from the Disney stable. Miss 8 3/4s was full of complex questions, namely, was Maleficent good or bad?
[Image Courtesy of IMDB Maleficent Poster Disney 2014]
Maleficent begins the film as a naive and happy fairy acting as guardian over her forest. Naturally there is a boy and his name is Stefan. Maleficent finds Stefan being confronted by her forest guards having stolen a jewel from the forest. Maleficent is enchanted to find a being similar to her and over time Maleficent and Stefan become friends and eventually as the two grow up together romance and love blooms. Their initial meeting in hindsight creates an important subtext for what is to follow.
Stefan is a servant to an ageing King who has been attempting to attack the forest for many years. Always rebounded by Maleficent and her fairy powers. In Stefan's presence he bids his guards to kill Maleficent and bring him proof - whoever does this shall be King and marry his daughter. Bound by ambition, Stefan does the unthinkable and betrays Maleficent. While he does not kill her, he disables Maleficent by removing her precious wings as proof of her death for the King on his deathbed. His reward for the betrayal of his love - a Kings title and a princesses hand in marriage.
What ensues is the transformation of Maleficent from naive trusting fairy to evil empress of the forest. This is where the plot falls back into the storyline of Sleeping Beauty with Maleficent placing the sleeping curse on King Stefan's first born child Princess Aurora. At this point sympathies naturally lie with the King who has transformed himself from betraying conman to statesman and family man.
While King Stefan works to protect his child, Maleficent starts to watch Aurora as she grows. Referring to her as the 'little beastie'. Over time Maleficent transforms from evil empress to protector and guardian of Aurora.
So here we have the second switch in roles for the two protagonists of the film. King Stefan transforms into madman blinded by a determination to protect his kingdom and his daughter from Maleficent. In doing so he withdraws completely from his daughters life. While the evil empress transforms into Aurora's guardian mentor thus opening her stone cold heart to the child. Maleficent tries desperately to undo her curse without success except for the proviso that it can be broken by her one true love.
Naturally on her 16th birthday Aurora's curse plays out and she is condemned to an eternal sleep. Maleficent upon hearing the curse has taken Aurora defies good sense and breaks into the castle to attend her 'little beastie'. As it turns out, the charming prince cannot undo what has been done. Instead Maleficent is Aurora's one true love, because of the depth of love similar to a mother and child.
King Stefan upon learning Maleficent is in his castle, brings together all his preparations for the destruction of the evil empress while totally blind to his daughter's true fate. In the final battle Aurora saves Maleficent by handing back her wings. Alas poor mad King Stefan cannot redeem his need for Melificent's destruction and it is he who ends up in the eternal sleep of death.
While I adored seeing Angelina Jolie in all her magnificence, the longer lasting effects of this film has been the provision of a wonderful lesson for Miss 8 3/4s. Maleficent began the story as a good and noble protector, then after her betrayal she became a cruel and vengeful empress of the forest. While a romantic loves betrayal led her into the darkness, a mother's love led her back to the light.
In King Stefan too we see transformation from thief, to loyal and loving man back to thief. But his story too becomes more complex when his daughter is born. At this stage he is a good statesman and enchanted father. Through Maleficent's revenge he transforms into an obsessed man of war to protect his child, so much so he detaches himself from the very person who can save him - Aurora.
The complex plot eloquently displayed one of the hardest lessons for both children and adults to comprehend, no man, woman or child is all good or all bad. Rather we are formed by not only our experiences but our choice in choosing who our true selves are led much by love rather than reaction.
Recently I again came across this lesson again from an unexpected source. I had the pleasure of reading Nobel Laureate Pearl S. Buck's book Imperial Woman. Imperial Woman is a fictionalised biography of Yehonala (Tz'u Hsi in Wade–Giles), who was a concubine of the Xianfeng Emperor and on his death became the de facto Empress and head of the Qing dynasty until her death in 1908. The story of Tzu Hsi is the story of the last Empress in China.
![]() |
| Image Courtesy of Books.Goolge.Com.Au |
Yehonala as portrayed by Pearl S. Buck is an intelligent and multi-talented woman who quickly understands the opportunities available to her by winning the Emperor's true favor. Yehonala gives birth to a son, not long after the Emperor's consort gives birth to a daughter. The paternity of her son is assigned to Yehonala's childhood sweetheart Jung Lu yet this secret is relentlessly protected throughout the book.
Yehenola gets the title of Tzu Hsi (or Cixi, The empress of the eastern palaces) and Sakota the Emperor's consort gets the title of Tzu An ( or Cian,The empress of the western palaces). Tz'u Hsi uses her time as the Emperor's favourite to study the history of the Chinese and Manchu dynasty's along with enriching her many talents.
After the birth of her son she puts all of her energies into forming him into the future Emperor and protecting his future rule. During the Emperor's reign Tz'u Hsi gains power by advising the Emperor on matters of state and also becoming the trusted ally of many in the Court. However, her advice is based on the study of history and deep respect for tradition. When 'foreign invaders' come to China issuing demands, tracks of land and foreign missionaries begin to spread the word of 'Christ' Tz'u Hsi advises the Emperor against any concessions to their demands. Foiling the foreigners for a number of years by delays and obfuscations. When the foreigners patience is exhausted they revert to invasion to gain a foothold in China with dire consequences. Following the death of the Emperor, Tz'u Hsi has to fight against plots to kill both herself and her son.
Using her allies and lifelong protector Jung Lu she manages to foil the plots against her. In a clever move she installs both herself and Tzu An as protectors of the Empire in her sons name. Her singular determination is to protect the dynasty for her son - she shows not mercy to those who plotted against her. Tz'u Hsi is also unforgiving of the concessions given in a treaty with the 'foreign invaders' to stop their invasion of China. At the same time, she is generous and loving of both her people and those who are loyal to her. Even to the extent that she provides Jung Lu with a wife. A lady of the court, who was the daughter of one of her enemies. Sadly, upon his marriage she realises that in order to protect their sons ascension to the Emperor's throne she must forgo any hope of a secret love affair. He remains her loyal adviser and guardian throughout his life.
Tz'u Hsi and Jung Lu's son become Emperor after twelve years. During these twelve years, Tz'u Hsi acts as both Empress and strict mentor allowing her co-Empress Tzu An only a veil of power and ensuring clever intimidation as every sign of the true Consort exerting her rightful power. During this phase of her rule, Tz'u Hsi single mindedly concentrates on her son and caretaking his Empire. Realisation of his unintentional betrayal dawns on Tz'u Hsi slowly over time. He is much closer to her co-Empress and accepts from her a mothers comfort, while only shows deferment to his true mother. When the Emperor takes a wife, he chooses one his mother objects too. He is not interested in the concubines Tz'u Hsi chooses for him. Instead he is deeply in love with his intelligent and strong consort.
The Emperor's marriage sees Tz'u Hsi's power deeply diminished. Further to this stinging betrayal of Tz'u Hsi is her sons affection for all things foreign. While Tz'u Hsi's rule of the Empire was founded in the past, the Emperor's rule is formed with a view to the future and this includes foreigners.
At this point in the novel, a reader's sympathy lies with Tz'u Hsi - she has sacrificed her own happiness and opportunity for true love in order to protect the Qing Dynasty for her son and her subjects. Though at the same time, the reader can understand Tz'u Hsi has been truley successful in mentoring her son to become Emperor. At this point the Dynasty has a chance to be ruled by a strong and intelligent ruler who is deeply in love with his wife the consort.
Here is where we see similarities to Maleficent. Tz'u Hsi's success is viewed by her as a betrayal. The Emperor's rule with a view to allowing concessions to foreigners is seen by Tz'u Hsi as a betrayal of her rule and a danger to the Dynasty. The true love between the Emperor and his consort is seen as a threat to her place as his elder and in true fact is also a threat to the power she has been used too.
Feeling betrayed Tz'u Hsi devises a plan to unseat the Consorts hold over her son by replacing his affections with a concubine of her choosing. After many attempts, Tz'u Hsi is finally successful. So successful her son falls into a secret and dangerous life led astray by his now favoured concubine. The Consort is pregnant and the Emperor is felled by a common disease contracted during one of his sordid forays. The Emperor dies. Tz'u Hsi encourages her pregnant daughter in law to commit suicide and replaces her son with a nephew. This point in the novel and perhaps history betrays the readers view of Tz'u Hsi as a clever and much admired protagonist.
From this point on the Qing Dynasty is ruled by the Empress Tz'u Hsi or 'Old Buddha' as she is commonly referred to. Her nephew, once Emperor against falls into the trap of favouring relations with foreigners and Tz'u Hsi again takes power back.
Enter the 'Boxer Rebellion' - a time in China where foreign missionaries and their converts were murdered. The Empress employs the help of the Boxers to try and rid her country of the 'foreign invaders'. Like a plague she thinks she can extinguish their spread and demands for recognition. The Rebellion is cruel, violent and heartless, also against Tz'u Hsi acts against the advice of her much loved and trusted Jung Lu, whom she has elevated to Imperial Adviser.
Once Tz'u Hsi has set the rebellion in motion and accepted the help of the Boxers, she quickly realises that the foreigners will see her as an enemy who must be destroyed. In order to attempt to save her place and her Empire she reaches out to foreign leaders, Emperors and Queens alike with excuses and placing the blame on the Boxers themselves. She is met with complete silence. Followed by advancing foreign armies determined to free their trapped and starving compatriots in Peking. Forced to flee by the powerlessness of her own armed forces against the invading armies, Tz'u Hsi goes further and further from Peking ignoring the sage advice of Jung Lu to make many concessions in order to make peace with the foreigners. Concessional peace will allow her Dynasty to continue but also allow modernity to spread across China.
Finally, accepting this is the only option she has to bring peace and stability to her people Tz'u Hsi agrees. Jung Lu however, dies shortly after and we see again the love struck Empress of kindness and generosity. Sadly though one whose Dynasty would end not long after her own life.
In her determination to uphold the tradition, etiquette and dynastic rule in true love of her people, Tz'u Hsi looses her true purpose and true self. Her purpose was to place a strong and clever Emperor on the throne. One who would serve the people, both Chinese and Manchurian to continue the great Empire China once was. Instead, through perceived betrayal Tz'u Hsi concentrates on holding onto power at all costs. The cost being an enlightened Emperor who could have perhaps held onto the Qing Dynasty and taken china into the 20th Century on her own terms.
Again, we see a guardian turned Empress who experiences betrayal and let's that betrayal overtake all the good in herself. Only to find much later that only through true love can she find herself again.
Maleficent is a developed character from the children's story Sleeping Beauty, and Tz'u Hsi a real life Empress who ruled over a country with Confucianism traditions share many important similarities. Both bore an important guardian role over a traditional and mysterious land and a much beloved child. By mysterious, I mean a society whose traditions and etiquette was misunderstood by outsiders. Both women were betrayed. One by her only love and the other by her duty to her only son. Yet both women experienced true love, yet in opposite hierarchy. Maleficent truly loved and was loved by Aurora her god daughter, while Tz'u Hsi's true love was Jung Lu, her childhood sweetheart and lifelong protector.
The overall greater lesson from these two comparative stories is how a beloved's betrayal led both women away from their true selves. If Pearl S. Buck's description of Tz'u Hsi is more truth than fiction, Tz'u Hsi truly loved not only Jung Lu but the people of China. Her intention was to keep power to rule for them. In this single minded determination, Tz'u Hsi may however, have been responsible for destroying the very Dynasty and legacy she was determined to protect. Maleficient however, had the Linda Woolverton and Charles Perrault's writers pen to erase a lasting legacy of revenge and turn her into the redeemed heroine of the story with a happy ending for all bar King Stefan. Both the fictional Maleficient and the real life Empress Tzu Hsi teach us that we are a summary of our experiences. To a child's eyes - no one is all bad or all good but it is how we choose to form ourselves based on experience that is what makes us who we are.
By three methods we may learn wisdom: First, by reflection, which is noblest; Second, by imitation, which is easiest; and third by experience, which is the bitterest.
Confucius



No comments:
Post a Comment